I left my job about a month ago and still haven't been back to receive my paycheck. I was talking with some former co-workers last night and they told me that the boss had told them they were holding my paycheck from me. They said it was because I drew on one of the bar mats. This is true, and I shouldn't have drawn on the bar mats, but it was with a ballpoint pen that I could probably wipe off. My boss actually said that she liked the way it looked after I drew on it. I know that makes no difference but it just shows they are using this as a reason to spite me. They are claiming the mat is an "antique" (I found another on Ebay for $5) and for that reason they will not pay me. They have not taken any damages out of the check or even discussed this with me...what should I do?
If you are in the US, your employer cannot legally withhold wages from you for any reason other than taxes or other legal deductions (medical,dental, 401K, etc). They can't even hold your check if you are responsible for a cash drawer and it comes up short.
What they can do is fire you. They can also sue you for damages that include replacing whatever was defaced/destroyed and generally the associated costs for bringing that suit to court.
So, if you want to make this go away and get paid, first find out your legal rights/responsibilities in the state where you worked. Every state has their own labor laws so you would need to understand what applies in your local area. Once you know that, you'll know exactly what to do, and what you are actually responsible for.
Parker IM Matte Silver Chrome Accents Ballpoint Pen Blk Ink Medium Point 1750429, Sheaffer VFM Matte Black Ballpoint Pen 9405-2, Giuliano Mazzuoli Lima 3+1 Matte Chrome Multifunction Ballpoint Pen / Pencil, Sheaffer 100 Matte Grey Ballpoint Pen & 0.7mm Pencil 9319-9, Sheaffer Sentinel Black Matte G/T Ballpoint Pen 327-2, Sheaffer 100 Matte Black Ballpoint Pen 9317-2, Sheaffer Prelude Black Matte G/T Ballpoint Pen 346-2, Sheaffer 100 Matte Navy Blue Ballpoint Pen & 0.7mm Pencil 9318-9, Sheaffer 100 Matte Navy Blue Ballpoint Pen 9318-2, Sheaffer Sentinel Matte Black N/T Ballpoint Pen 9071-2, PARKER INSIGNIA BALL POINT PEN MATTE BLACK NEW IN BOX (Listing #2), Rotring 600 Newton Ballpoint Pen, Matte Black, Rotring 600 Old Style Ballpoint Pen, Matte Black, Series 3, Vintage Pens X2 Reform West Germany Fountain Pen Ball Point Pen Matte Blue+Gold, NEW WATERFORD ARISTA MATTE BLACK BALLPOINT PEN, Vintage TIffany & Co. Sterling Silver & Black Matte Ball Point Pen, NEW CROSS CLASSIC MATTE BLACK / GOLD BALLPOINT PEN & MECHANICAL PENCIL SET, SHEAFFER TRZ MODEL 50 Black Matte Ball Point Pen in Box, Matte Gunmetal Oversized Ballpoint Pen w Magnetic Sculpture Executive Desk Toy , Matte Chrome & Maple Ballpoint Pen with Putting Green Golf Executive Desk Toy , White And Black Swirl & Matte Silver Mini Ballpoint Pen, Green Swirl & Matte Silver Mini Ballpoint Pen, Sheaffer Imperial Matte Black & Gold Ballpoint Pen - 1980's - New, Black Chrome LEVENGER TRUGRIP Ballpoint Pen Soft Matte Lacquer Writes, Parker Sonnet Matte Black Ball Point Pen CT NEW, CROSS CENTURY III ROYAL BLUE MATTE BALLPOINT PEN A8, MONT BLANC "NOBLESSE" BALL POINT PEN (MATTE STEEL), Cross Morph Ballpoint Pen/Black Matte Finish "New", PARKER ESPRIT MATTE RED MULTI FUNCTION BALLPOINT PEN & PDA NEW IN BOX, Delta Airlines Twist Ballpoint Pen Grey Matte Logo in Acrylic on Angle Cap,